After almost three years here, I’d like to share my thoughts on all this mess. To be honest, my motivation to upload anything here, or even to make models in general, has dropped below zero because of all these scammers on CGTrader who file chargebacks and use stolen cards.
Like many of my friends from CG, we’ve developed a theory that the way refunds and chargebacks are handled may be contributing to the problem. Given the scale of refunds and the lack of transparency around them, sellers naturally have questions about where these funds actually go and how refund decisions are made. Otherwise, how can you explain why registration still hasn’t been made more secure? Adding proper authentication linked to a phone number or social media account would probably filter out at least 70% of the scammers.
Around 20–30% of my sales end up being refunded, sometimes even 3–6 months after the purchase! So not only has the payout system been changed several times already, but we also have to deal with this. The site is basically wide open to scammers.
On top of that, our revenue share keeps getting reduced, while the requirements for reaching the highest tier are completely unrealistic.
It has gotten to the point where I barely make any models anymore. If I used to just consider moving to another platform, now I’m seriously thinking about leaving CGTrader altogether and selling my work elsewhere.
I’ve also been contacting support periodically for several years now. They take a very long time to respond, and I’ve repeatedly tried to explain how the platform could be better protected. All I ever hear is, “We’re working on it.”
But in reality, nothing seems to have been done. Theft, theft, theft — and you end up giving your work away for free. Let’s be honest about it.
After three years, there still doesn’t seem to be any meaningful improvement in user protection: no stronger registration process, no effective protection against fraudulent chargebacks, just promises.
At this point, I can practically predict when a refund is going to happen just by looking at the buyer’s login. It feels like I’m constantly knocking on a closed door called “Support.”
I know more than one major platform where ignoring these kinds of problems and constantly cutting creators’ revenue shares eventually led to people leaving, and the platform ultimately went under.
Considering CGTrader’s relatively substantial earnings, all of this seems extremely strange to anyone who understands how business works.