Blog

Visual industries news, insights from CGTrader marketplace, company announcements, and some inspiration for your upcoming 3D model. Find amazing stories from the community and beyond. How spaceship model end-up in VR experience, how challenge to model a sword and the win shape further modeling career and many more amazing stories can be found on this blog.

Real or Fake? Quiz on stunning photorealistic food 3D models

September 1st, 2014

Real or Fake? Quiz on stunning photorealistic food 3D models

Warning! This quiz contains dangerously yummy images of cakes, breads, seafood and various delicious meals; not all of them are real, though. 3D artists are throwing you a challenge: CAN you tell, which of these images are computer-generated?

Is this image real or fake?

1/16 Mason Jar Layered Lunch

2/16 Raspberry Day

3/16 Bits of Bread

4/16 King Prawns

5/16 Iced Coffee

6/16 Lemons

7/16 Breakfast

8/16 Hot Chocolate

9/16 Blueberry Muffin

10/16 Italian Lunch

11/16 Dessert

12/16 Basket of Buns

13/16 Early Morning Breakfast

14/16 Sweet Hawaiian Dinner Rolls

15/16 The Ultimate Tia Maria Chocolate Fudge Cake

16/16 Red Grapes

Comments

Tell us what you think!

juoolz wrote
(DONT READ UNLESS YOU HAVE ALREADY TAKEN THE QUIZ) That was fun. The last image "Red Grapes" is mind blowing!! I must have spend a good 5 min looking at it and still believed it to be a photo. Infact the only slight doubt was the lighting on the leaf in the very bottom right and (Now that iv spent a little more time on it) the patterns in some leaves match! However absolutly amazing :)
niemeyer-julius wrote
for some reason i see it on the first sight if a picture is fake or not but it takes me a while to define why 15 out of 16 right !!
rollerphreak wrote
Got all 16 right, though there were 2 where I had scratched my head for a few seconds. Seems I spent to much time rendering... :)
lh123 wrote
I got 16/16 (Spoliers) 1. The jar on the right has a red piece in it with a liquid surface tension outline where it's touching the jar. I've never seen an artist go to that length. 2. Needs more dirt/damage. 3. Noise around glasses in top left. Bread on right looks like it has a photo texture (lighting info in the diffuse). 4. The pan is perfectly cross-sectioned! 5. This one was tough, but the ice cubes looked real 6. There would be some motion blur if real lemons were thrown up like that. 7. Too much noise 8. The highlight in the top/back rim of the red cup has aliasing 9. A lot of organic detail. An artist wouldn't put a seam inside the bowl either. 10. Pasta just doesn't look right at all. 11. Tough, but I think there's chromatic abberation on the floor board which a photographer wouldn't want. 12. Textures look a bit fake, perhaps a photo texture 13. Noise in bottom right 14. Difficult, but no noise at all, bread has some translucency and cloth is very real 15. Just looks real 16. Those two grapes at the top of the main bunch have both got the same little dent. Plus, the render looks high dynamic range compared to a photo. Also if a photographer takes a photo, they have to be in the scene which means they effect the lighting with their presence; most artists never put a 'photographer' object in their scene so front facing surfaces are often lighter than they should be.
gera-nataliya wrote
Nice try, but I got all answers right and I am not a 3D artist neither a photographer. Although I do see much of 3D works and I love 3D art.
etamas3d wrote
The 4th image reminds me this page, are you sure not they made it ? https://www.behance.net/BrightParameters and the lemon scene looks like if a screenshot from this piece by Alex Roman: https://vimeo.com/16239432 btw nice set :)
glabs wrote
Though all are amazing but Raspberry Day is awesome model, it floats on the top of the chart in my decision.
patricia-klein wrote
13 out of 16! Red grapes almost fooled me! I said almost... :-)
jonnydjango wrote
15 of 16... that was fun! But the artist wich made the Bread image is named Andrew Price... the "w" is missing...
chririz wrote
real
miledrizk wrote
i got 15 out of 16! wasn't easy though! great CGI work! Bravo!! :))
kinoko wrote
I wish I could model and render food real as this. The only one I got wrong was the 11th one because it looks so real and yummy. :)
smorrison1014 wrote
I got all correct! That was fun! I will admit a few stumped me, but after close inspection I could tell whether they were real or not. I'm sure a lot of people have been stumped though and thought one was real when it was in fact fake. This was cool.
sergtf wrote
real
ieva-lickiene wrote
"Raspberry day" got me bad :) It just looks too real.
joey-blendernut wrote
I saw a movie cover, and said without a doubt 3d... Made me curious as to how good I've gotten over the years at spotting 3d vs real. 16/16 no sweat. 1. The burger was too convincing. A 3D artist would just use displacement, and at max, model it out, but would never smash it against the glass and change the color. On top of that, the lettuce didn't appear to be alpha planes. 2. The hairs on a red raspberry are on the top of the berry's little, mini berry things. I'm picky, not smart. These hairs are in the crevices instead. And the small hairs are a nice touch though, and fairly accurate. 3. Ugh... Too easy. The board has damage all over it, in places it wouldn't (the handle)... Or at least it shouldn't have as much damage there. The loaf of rye bread is super flat looking. The doughnuts are odd looking. Look like rubber. The canvas shader is lacking something as well though. Great job on the UV unwrapping on the wood boards though. Oh, also, there is tons of grain in the glasses in the background. Obviously you didn't add the dof in post, so it affected the render... Quite terribly I'm afraid. 4. It's good, but looked off. The squished texture on the edge of what is the edge of a cut pan confirmed. Also, if the pan was cut in half like that, there would be a different texture to it from the cut. Oh and drops of oil on the side of the pan. 5. The ICE! That stuff is awesome. The wood is more saturated where it's wet. The water also shows where the glass was moved around for taking photos... Too good for 3d I'm afraid. 6. This one gave me the most trouble. I thought it was a trick question, because the lemons were falling, which is a common trick for 3D Artists... But, then the pores confirmed it's fake. Real lemons have small dark pores, and then actual pores... As well as small bumps resembling pulp. I did a lemon a few months ago, and had to study the skin quite a bit... 7. The noise on the orange in the basket was the first clue. The blueberries being completely diffused was the next. The silverware being perfectly polished was the next. And the final nail in the coffin, was the chair having a single wood texture, as if it was one piece of wood. In addition, the texture is tiled, quite badly. 8. Flat texture on top, combined with unrealistic reflections, and the chocolate texture being the same all around. 9. Right off, the blueberries where way to realistic to be fake. The blueberry juice oozing out is another detail a 3d artist would miss. The cooked blueberries are very glossy, another detail most would miss. Definitely real. 10. A noodle is hanging midair on the left side. The silverware is super super polished. Too much. The leaves are too saturated. The sauce is translucent, like jello. The sauce also fails to interact with the noodles. 11. Uh... Last I checked, blueberries don't float above the water surface. Also, very flat texture on the surface. 12. The basket is too polished. Rope texture appears to be repeating. The biscuits' textures are definitely duplicated though. 13. First of all, I've seen the tutorial, I'm a blender artist. But this has tons of errors anyhow. The inside of the bread is flat, and the silverware is also way too polished, and there is grain in the jam. Then the lighting is mediocre. Honestly, this needs a lot of work. 14. Butter on the edges of the pan... No 3D Artist would remember that. And no 3d artist would work hard enough to add those. 15. That top... So many simpler things could be there in it's place, but it's super complex... I can only imagine the topology if it was fake. Definitely real. 16. A little tricky, but I've experienced this artifact in leaves with the backs of leaves before. Still the camera's iso may have been too high on a clear day, I needed more to condemn it on. The texture on the leaves was all the exact same. To top it off, it doesn't look like the branches had proper UV Unwrapping... Oh, and the berries are super translucent, but seems like there's nothing inside. No seeds, no little stringy things. Like I said, picky, not smart. Haha... Terrific photos and models. I suppose this is outdated though, and I think today's 3D art could easily fool me... Good show Dear Watson.